Skip to main content

Full text of "Matrix-Product Ansatz for Excited States of Fractional Quantum Hall Systems"

See other formats


Matrix- Pro duct Ansatz for Excited States of 



Fractional Quantum Hall Systems 

Zheng- Yuan Wang and Masaaki Nakamura 

Department of Physics, Tokyo Institute of Technology, 0-Okayama, 
Meguro-ku, Tokyo 152-8551, Japan 

E-mail: wang@stat.phys. titech. ac.jp, masaaki@stat.phys. titech. ac.jp 
(Received January 24, 2013) 

Recently, it was discussed that the v = 1/3 fractional quantum Hall state can be expressed 
by a one-dimensional lattice model with an exact matrix-prduct ground state, when toroidal 
boundary conditions are assumed for a narrow strip [Phys. Rev. Lett. 109 (2012) 016401]. In 
this article, we discuss how the excitation spectra of this system are calculated analytically 
based on the matrix-product formalism. We introduce variational wave functions for various 
momenta and optimize them. The obtained spectra of the charge neutral excitations show 
the magneto-roton behavior. 

KEYWORDS: fractional quantum Hall effect, thin-torus limit, matrix product state, exactly 
solvable model, excited states, magneto-roton 



1. Introduction 

In recent years, there have been theoretical efforts to study the fractional quantum Hall 
(FQH) states around the thin-torus (or Tao-Thouless, TT) limit, where the original 2D 
system in a magnetic field with toroidal boundary conditions is reduced to ID lattice models 
with short-range interactions [1-4]. This approach is justified because the FQH states in 
this anisotropic system are known to be adiabatically connected to the isotropic cases [2]. 
From this point of view, the authors with Bergholtz have shown that the v = 1/3 Laughlin 
state [5] can be expressed by a ID model with an exact matrix-product (MP) ground state [6]. 
In this article, we give the details to obtain the excitation spectra of this model based on 
the MP wave function with variational parameters which partially mentioned in Ref. [6] , and 
generalize this calculation to arbitrally momenta and obtain roton behavior of the excitation 
spectra [7). 

2. Fractional quantum Hall states on torus geometries 

We consider a model of N e interacting electrons in a magnetic field Bona torus boundary 
conditions with circumferences L\ and L 2 for x and y-directions, respectively. For simplicity, 
we normalize x,y,Li,L2 by magnetic length Is = y 'ch/eB. When the torus is pierced by 
N s magnetic flux quanta, boundary conditions require the relation L\L 2 = 2irN s . In Landau 
gauge (A = Byx), a complete basis of N s degenerate single-particle states in the lowest 
Landau level can be chosen as 



ipi(x,y) 



^exp 



i (gi + L 2 j) x 



exp 



(1) 



1 



where the guiding center of the Gaussian function in y-direction is given by the quantized 
momentum in x-direction with i = 0, 1, • • • , N s — 1. In this basis, any translationally-invariant 
2D Hamiltonian with two-body interactions assumes the following ID lattice model, 

^ = X/ Vkrn, Vkm = ^ ^km C i+m C l+k C i+k+m C i ' ( 2 ) 
|m|<fe<Af s /2 i 

where the matrix-element V& m specifies the amplitude for a pair hopping process where two 
particles separated k + m sites hop m steps to opposite directions (note that m can be 
negative). The m = terms are the electrostatic repulsions, the matrix elements are real and 
antisymmetric functions for interchange of k and m. This model conserves the center of mass 
coordinate defined by K = Y^h=i ( m od N s ) with n = c\c i} which is identified as the total 
momentum in x-direction [see Eq. (1)]. 

For small L\ the matrix elements V^ m are simplified considerably: Since one finds that 
for generic interaction, the m/0 terms are exponentially suppressed as 

V km ~V M ^v{-^ 2 m 2 /L\). (3) 

Therefore, in the TT limit L\ — > 0, m 7^ terms in the original Hamiltonian (2) can be 
neglected, so that the Hamiltonian can be rewritten as Utt = Y^i Vko n i+j n j- Then the 
ground state is obtained at filling factor v = 1/3 is gapped, and three-fold degenerate charge 
density wave state with three sites periodicity, |^o) = 1 010| 010| 010 • • •). A system of thin but 
finite torus can be considered by taking the leading hopping terms Vkm ( m 7^ 0) into account 
for the TT state \^ ). 

3. Matrix-product ground state for v = 1/3 Laughlin state 

The exactly solvable model for v = 1/3 states [6] can be obtained by truncating the 
Hamiltonian (2) up to the third nearest interactions [k + \m\ < 3) as an approximation in 
the vicinity of the TT limit. When we further assume L2 — > 00 limit, the matrix elements 
of the pseudo potential for v = 1/3 Laughlin state [8] satisfies the conditions = V10V30 

and V20 > 0. Then the Hamiltonian is rewritten as = Yli[Q\Qi + -^/-^h where Qi = 

aoQ_|_iQ + 2 + aiCiQ+3 and Pi = f3oCiCi + 2 with ao,ai,/3o £ R. This Hamiltonian apparently 
has positive expectation values (^1/3) > 0, and the following wave function as the exact 
ground state 

I*) = II^ 1 + te f+i c !+2 c i+3 c i) l*o) , t = -ai/oo, (4) 

i 

since Qi 1^1/3) = P% ^1/3) = 0, Vi is satisfied. This is three-fold degenerate but can be shown 
to be unique ground state for each center-of-mass sectors. 

The wave function (4) can be written in a MP form 1*1/3) = tr[<7i<72 ■ ■ ■ 9N e ] [9,10] 
where the matrix gi is identified in the following way. First, we introduce the 5 = 1 spin 
representation for the three-sites unit cell as 1 010) — > |o), 1 001 ) — > |+) and 1 100) — > |— ). One 
finds that the possible configurations of the nearest two spins are |oo) + t \-\ — ) + |o+) + 1— o) + 
|— +), so that if we express the relations in the following 3x3 matrix 



9i 



/__!-), f. \o) z /_+|+> 

fo-\-)i /oo|o)j /o+|+), 

/+_!-), j+oio), / ++ |+) 



(5) 



its non-vanishing elements are identified as f OQ = f Q+ = /_ Q = / h = 1 and / + _ = t. Next, 

we reduce the obtained 3x3 matrix to a 2 x 2 form by changing the base from (t |— ) , |o) , |+)) 



2 



to (t\-) + |o) ,|+)) as 



t\~)i 







(6) 



The matrix (6) has a 4 x 4 transfer matrix G = gj <8> gj with only two eigenvalues X± = 
(1 ± yj At 2 + 1) /2. The argument for the Hamiltonian with an exact MP wave function can 
also be extended to general v = 1/q Laughlin states [11]. 

4. Variational wave functions for excited states 



We derive excitation spectra at v = 1/3 by a variational method. In the TT limit, 
the charge neutral excited states include one 01-type and one 0-type domain walls that 
carry fractional charges e* = e/3 and e* = — e/3, respectively. These states \^>^ K=1 ) = 
|010|0|01|010|010 - - ->, |*o^ =2 ) = |010|0|010|01|010 - - •>. are classified by the center of 
mass coordinate relative to the ground state which is related to the momentum of the in- 
direction. Now we consider the variational wave functions that consists of configurations 
generated from \^q~ k ) by applying the Hamiltonian %i/ 3 . For AK = 1, there are following 
exchange processes, |010|001|010|010 • • •) -»• |010|001|001|100 • • •) -»• 1 010| 000| 1 10| 100 • • •) -»• 
|010|001|001| 100 • • •). Since the interactions in are limited within the third neighbors, 

there is no exchange process across the defects. We can rewrite these processes in the 5 = 1 
spin variables by inserting vacancies appropriately (between the two l's) [12,13] as 



1010101 010 I 010 I 010- 

O OOO 

[010 1 1 001 1 010 I 100- 



•) -»• |010 |0| 010 1 001 1 100 - - -> - 

o o + — 

•) -> |010 |0| 010 1 001 1 100 - - -> . 



(7) 



We redefine the site indices so that the defect comes to the edge, and introduce an ansatz 
with variational parameters u and v as \ty AK=1 ) = tr[g[g 2 g 3 ■ ■ ■ 9m -i9'n\-> where 



9i = 



u\o) 1 
t\~) 1 





w|o)i 



// _ 

9N e = 



t\~) 








(8) 



For the case AK > 2, the ansatz should include three variational parameters u, v and w as 
l^ A ^> = tr bif 2 • • • 9 K -i9k9 k +2 • • • 9 Ne - 1 9N e ] with 

u \°+)i,i+i + v \+°)i,i+i 



in 

9i = 



00 



tu\-o) iti+1 +tv\o-) 



tw\-+hi 



When we calculate the compressibility, we need to shrink the system size as N s 



(9) 
lby 



removing from the root state. Then only one 01-type domain wall (|- ■ • 010|010|01|010 • • •)) 

should be considered, so that the ansatz becomes |^ _ ) = tr[g'{'g 3 g 4 ■ ■ ■ g Ne _ 1 }- 

These variational wave functions for N e — > 00 can be optimized analytically by using 
the undetermined coefficient method. Fig. 1 (a) shows the excitation spectra obtained by 
the MP ansatz for the infinite system as functions of L\. These well agree with the results 
obtained from the infinite systems by exact diagonalization (ED). The deviation in the large 
L\ region is due to the finite size effect which appears through A_/A + . We also get a finite 
value of E(N S — 1) for iV e — > 00, reflecting that the Laughlin state is incompressible k~ 1 = 
lim 7Vs ^ 00 (iV s /47rZ2)[ J E(Ar s _i) + J E(Ar s + i)_2 J E s (iV s )] -> 00 where E(N S + 1) = E S {N S ) = 0. 
Fig. 1 (b) shows the neutral excitation spectra obtained by the MP ansatz for AK = 1-6. The 
AK = 2 state is always the lowest, and the excitation energy converges to a constant value 
when AK is increased as shown in the inset. This captures a character of the magneto-roton 
behavior in the FQH state [7]. These results are also consistent with a recent analysis based 
on spherical coordinate and the Jack polynomials [14]. 




AK=1 MP 
ED 

AK=2 MP 
ED 

E(N S - 1) MP 
ED 

5 6 7 



0.05 

0.04 

ty 0.03 
< 

0.02 
0.01 
0.00 



(b) 












{ \ 














(AK=1 

2 








■ 


3 

4 

5 








J 


6 












: A£ 





9 10 11 12 



5 6 



10 11 12 



Fig. 1. (a) Comparison of excitation spectra obtained by the MP anzats for infinite systems and 
those by exact diagonalization (ED) for a finite system N s — 27. (b) Neutral excitation spectra for 
different momenta AK — 1-6 derived from the MP anzats for a infinite system. The inset shows the 
excitation spectra as function of AK at L± = 8 which show a magneto-roton minimum. 



5. Conclusion 

We have studied the excitation spectra of the u = 1/3 FQH states considering toroidal 
boundary conditions in the vicinity of the Tao-Thouless limit. In this region, the original 
2D system can be mapped onto a ID lattice model with short-range interactions which has 
the exact MP ground state. We have introduced "ansatz" for the excited state as the MP 
state with defects and variational parameters, and derived the excitation spectra analytically. 
The excitation spectrum with a fractional charge reflects the incompressibility of fractional 
quantum Hall states. The charge neutral excitations behave like the roton mode. 

6. Acknowledgment 

We thank Emil J. Bergholtz for the related collaboration in Ref. [6]. Z.-Y. W. and M. N. 
acknowledge support from the Global Center of Excellence Program "Nanoscience and Quan- 
tum Physics" of the Tokyo Institute of Technology. M. N. also acknowledges support from 
Grant-in-Aid No.23540362 by MEXT. 

References 

[1] R. Tao and D. J. Thouless: Phys. Rev. B 28 (1983) 1142. 

[2] E. H. Rezayi and F. D. M. Haldane: Phys. Rev. B 50 (1994) 17199. 

[3] E. J. Bergholtz and A. Karlhede: Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 026802. 

[4] A. Seidel, H. Fu, D. -H. Lee, J. M. Leinaas and J. Moore: Phys. Rev. Lett. 95 (2005) 266405. 
[5] R. B. Laughlin: Phys. Rev. Lett. 50 (1983) 1395. 

[6] M. Nakamura, Z. -Y. Wang and E. J. Bergholtz: Phys. Rev. Lett. 109 (2012) 016401. 
[7] S. M. Girvin, A. H. MacDonald and P. M. Platzman: Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 (1985) 581; 

Phys. Rev. B 33 (1986) 2481. 
[8] S. A. Trugman and S. A. Kivelson: Phys. Rev. B 31 (1985) 5280. 
[9] M. Fannes, B. Nachtergale and R. F. Werner: Europhys. Lett. 10 (1989) 633; 
Commun. Math. Phys. 144 (1992) 443. 
[10] A. Kliimper, A. Schadschneider and J. Zittartz: Z. Phys. B 87 (1992) 281; 

Europhys. Lett. 24 (1993) 293. 
[11] Z. -Y. Wang and M. Nakamura: arXiv:1206.3071v2. 

[12] M. Nakamura, Z. -Y. Wang and E. J. Bergholtz: J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 302, 012020 (2011). 

[13] Z. -Y. Wang, S. Takayoshi and M. Nakamura: Phys. Rev. B 86 (2012) 155104. 

[14] B. Yang, Z.-X. Hu, Z. Papic and F. D. M. Haldane: Phys. Rev. Lett. 108 (2012) 256807. 



4